Word: claggart
(lookup in dictionary)
(lookup stats)
Dates: during 1951-1951
Sort By: most recent first
(reverse)
...takes place aboard H.M.S. Indomitable in 1798, the year after the British mutiny at the Nore. Billy Budd is a handsome, blue-eyed, stammering young sailor who radiates innocence and good will, and is a favorite with the whole ship. The one exception is the master-at-arms, John Claggart, a figure of Mephistophelean evil, who, hating all goodness, cannot but hate Billy Budd and plot his destruction. He accuses Billy, in the presence of high-principled Captain Vere, of fomenting mutiny...
Shocked by the accusation, blocked by his stammer from denying it, Billy can only strike at Claggart, with a blow that kills him. At the subsequent court-martial, the Captain is agonized between his duty to "war's child," the Act of Mutiny, and his compassion for what might be his own child. But the tyranny of law, however harsh, he finds less hateful than the tyranny of lawlessness; and he decrees that Billy Budd must hang...
...conflict of these two prototypes is immediate. Billy seeks the friendship of the Master-at-Arms, and Claggart seeks the destruction of Billy. Between them stands Captain Edward Vere. He, alone of the three, can recognize both good and evil, and he is also the only real human being. When Billy strikes and kills Claggart, it is Vere who must judge the offender. Billy has "broken the compromise between good and evil" and order must be restored. The Captain can only ask Billy to "pray for those who must choose...
Symbolic characters can be used in a drama as well as in a novel, but on the stage they must be more than mere symbols. In "Billy Budd," Claggart and Billy never assume human complexity, and this is the greatest weakness of the play. The performance of Torin Thatcher as Claggart is an attempt to hint at a human character where, in reality, there is none. Charles Nolte is more successful as Billy because he does not exceed the narrow limits of the part. He is convincing in his simplicity. Dennis King is superb in the best conceived and written...
There is no love element to confuse the plot--"Billy Budd" has an all-male cast. But there are other distractions, apart from the distilled characters of Billy and Claggart. The early dialogue contains too many quick jumps from the humblest prose to polysyllabic poetry, and the first act is talkly and slowpaced. The last two acts, however, are far more convincing and dramatic. This improvement is probably due more to the appearance of Dennis King and better writing than to any effort by director Norris Houghton, whose work is often uninspired. Paul Morrison has designed some excellent, atmospheric sets...