Word: vincent
(lookup in dictionary)
(lookup stats)
Dates: all
Sort By: most recent first
(reverse)
Since late 1951, the loyalty of John Carter Vincent, career diplomat who helped shape the disastrous U.S. China policy of the '40s, has been under heavy attack and review. Three times a State Department board cleared him. Then, last December, President Harry Truman's own board found reasonable doubt of Vincent's loyalty (chiefly because of his proCommunist, anti-Nationalist views on China) and recommended his dismissal. Dean Acheson let the case hang over for the new Administration...
...Secretary of State has a legal right to withhold the details of his decision, but Vincent's case has larger implications than a run-of-the-mill dismissal. Many mistakes are made in policy making, but top-ranking career officers are seldom fired because of this. The combination of accusations of disloyalty and firing for lack of confidence suggests that Vincent's loyalty is in question...
...exercising his privilege of silence, Dulles leaves the cloud of suspicion over Vincent. He also makes one wonder whether or not he is sacrificing the man to the accusations of the public. Loyalty within the State Department was made a huge issue during the past election, and it is only natural that congressmen have questioned and will continue to question those officials who participated in policy-making under Democratic administration. If the Secretary of State allows accusations to be tantamount to guilt, he is going to encourage a lot of muckrakers to hound his and other government departments...
...Vincent has been retired for incompetence, as Dulles implies, the Secretary of State should publicize these mistakes. Incompetence is a lesser sin than disloyalty, and a few senators believe that Dulles is glossing over details to prevent any more probing into Vincent's past activities...
Dulles has, then, aroused both those who think he is covering up for Vincent and those who feel he has cowardly sacrificed him to prevent unpleasant accusations directed at his department. He can only clear the air by baring all the facts of the matter...